Fake or unfair reviews are a big problem for digital platforms. But popular Chinese food delivery app Meituan is trying a creative way to tackle this - let the users decide!

In this week's edition, we explore Meituan's "user jury" feature that has users vote on removing unreasonable complaints. It transforms content moderation into casual gameplay while aligning decisions with community norms.

The Rise of Fake Reviews

Fake and misleading reviews have become rampant across e-commerce platforms and delivery apps. Paying for fake 5-star reviews or sabotaging a business with fake 1-star reviews can significantly skew consumer opinions and purchase behavior.

Platforms dedicate extensive resources to identifying and removing fake reviews, but it remains an uphill battle. And even when reviews are real, conflicts still arise between emotional customers and merchants defending themselves.

Meituan, China's largest food delivery platform, devised an ingenious way to handle disputable reviews: let the users judge through a public voting system!

Introducing Little Mei's Juries

Meituan's "Little Mei's Juries" feature allows users to participate in resolving disputes between customers and restaurants. Users vote on whether unreasonable complaints should be removed from the platform.

Over 6 million users have participated in "jury duty," with the majority being college students looking to kill time between classes or while waiting for food deliveries.

Casual Gameplay, Serious Impacts

On the surface, Little Mei's Juries makes judging complaints into a casual game. Users can view cases, vote if a review seems unreasonable, and share interesting cases on social media. It's light-hearted entertainment.

But underneath lies a smart, crowdsourced moderation system. By having users judge the reasonableness of reviews, Meituan effectively filters out many fake or unfair complaints. It upholds standards of honesty and prevents abuse of the review system.

Meituan rewards "quality jury comments" with small prizes to encourage thoughtful participation. This prevents random voting.

Why It Works

There are several reasons why Little Mei's Juries works well:

Efficiency

It massively improves the efficiency of resolving review disputes. Previously, Meituan's content moderators had to evaluate every report manually. Now, unreasonable reviews are quickly brought to a public vote.

Transparency

The public jury system brings full transparency into how decisions are made. Users can see the case details and jury comments rather than simply seeing a review removed without explanation. This builds trust.

Alignment With Community Values

Crowdsourced votes align verdicts with the values and opinions of the user community rather than just the platform or a single moderator. Reviews perceived as unfair by the community get removed.

Uncovering Fraud

Sometimes, the juries uncover signs of fraudulent reviews that Meituan's algorithms missed. The collective intelligence of users helps strengthen fraud detection.

Entertainment Value

Participating users find the experience fun and even addicting. It feels like playing an online game while waiting for food. This entertainment value is what draws millions of users to engage.

Concerns and Challenges

However, Meituan's public jury system also faces some criticisms and challenges:

• Work Offloading: Some users complain the feature offloads responsibilities from Meituan's paid moderators onto users working for free. Is it exploiting users for labor?
• Bias: Reviews focusing on marginalized groups may face greater bias among jurors. How can biases be mitigated?
• Manipulation: As a public system, there is also the risk of manipulation by malicious actors deliberately attacking or defending targets.
• Scale: Can such a system work effectively across Meituan's over 500 million users and 6 million daily orders? There are limits to crowdsourced moderation.

Key Takeaways for Digital Platforms

Meituan's user jury feature offers inspirational ideas for digital platforms:

• Engagement - Well-designed voting/feedback systems can increase user engagement and sense of ownership.
• Efficiency - Crowdsourcing moderation of certain content types improves efficiency and catches things algorithms miss.
• Trust - Community-aligned governance builds user trust and prevents abuse of systems.

However, balancing business needs and user experience is critical for success. Companies exploring similar approaches should consider the following:

• Incentives to encourage participation
• Guidelines and algorithms to prevent manipulation
• Safeguards against bias risks
• Scaling limitations of crowdsourced models

Testing different governance models can lead to more democratic and sustainable platforms. The future lies in creative human-centric approaches rather than pure automation.

The GIO Team

About The Good Design | Center of Excellence Newsletter

For digital leaders aiming to drive growth through human-centric innovation, the Good Design Center of Excellence newsletter offers an inside look at GIO's approach. You'll gain strategic insights through digestible videos and articles to bridge the gap between vision and execution.

Seeking to unlock the future? Who better to provide the key than Generation Z themselves?

Good Ideas Only will conduct an immersive discovery sprint to reveal transformational insights into Gen Z behaviors and preferences. A limited number of exclusive sponsorships are available for enterprises seeking an inside track to engage this powerful consumer demographic. You can take advantage of this opportunity to gain proprietary intelligence tailored to your brand's innovation needs.

Good Ideas Only is a strategy and design studio that takes an outside-in approach to identify upcoming opportunities. Our "Good to Know" series provides leaders with strategic foresight on evolving consumer behavior and technology trends. We would appreciate your feedback on the first episode and suggestions for future topics. Feel free to respond if you have any problems you would like us to mull over. Our team of innovators and designers is here to help you bridge the gap between your vision and its execution.

Miami | Atlanta | New York | LA